“The Fifth Avenue Story Society” Review

“The Fifth Avenue Story Society,” by Rachel Hauck, is a great book for those of you who like modern Christian fiction! The setting is current day New York City and the five main characters all receive mysterious invitations to a meeting in a 19th century room at the Fifth Avenue Library. The characters are well developed and likeable:

Jett – a college literature professor who is working on his dissertation. 

Lexa – an successful executive assistant at a trendy restaurant chain. 

Coral – a high profile owner of a cosmetic company.

Chuck – an Uber driver and divorced dad.

Ed – a retired widower.

Each of the characters has a detailed backstory, including Jett and Lexa who used to be married to each other. 
I enjoyed learning more about each person as the chapters unfolded. There are hidden secrets, tragic events and successes that have happened during the course of each character’s life. Their “mysterious society” becomes a bond of friendship that begins to change lives for the better. There is also a strong thread of romance throughout the book and a powerful message of hope. 


“The Fifth Avenue Story Society” is probably not a huge “award winner,” but I did enjoy it. I found myself wanting to continue reading ‘just one more page’ to find out what turn the story would take. Each chapter was a refreshing, pleasant read for me and I recommend it to all who need a reminder that hope is always there for us.

Leave a Reply

This summer, Plant a Seed, Read at the library for our summer reading challenge! Log the minutes you read to earn badges and rewards!
Completion of this challenge requires 600 minutes (100 books for pre-readers) of reading. Each 100 minutes (15 books) of reading will reward you with 2 tickets to enter into the prize drawing on Beanstack, and readers age 0-12 will also get a prize of their choice from the prize box! Fully completing the challenge will reward you with an extra 10 tickets! Once you have earned your completion badge, stop by the front desk to enter the GRAND PRIZE DRAWING.
All prizes and incentives must be picked up in person at the library by August 1st, 2026.

Graphic for the Plant a Seed, Read, Summer Reading Challenge.

Visit the StoryWalk at Lakeview Park to experience a brand new story every six weeks. Library staff select a children’s book to go with the seasons or upcoming events. The current book is “The Bad Seed” by Jory John and Pete Oswald.

Book cover of "The Bad Seed" by Jory John and Pete Oswald.

Discover more from Watseka Public Library

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading